Nutley NJ Housing Market Update: Fall 2026

Nutley NJ Housing Market Update: Fall 2026

The short answer: Nutley is still a seller-leaning market this fall, but it's a calmer one than it was in the summer. In the three months ending October 2026, Nutley homes sold for a median of $679,527, which is 7.0% higher than a year earlier. They went under contract in a median of 33 days and closed at about 103% of list price on average. There are fewer homes for sale than last year, and also fewer sales. That points to a tight market that is cooling with the season, not one that is turning.

Data note: Unless I say otherwise, Nutley figures come from Redfin's public Data Center file for the rolling three months of August 1 to October 31, 2026 (updated November 3, 2026). Redfin builds it from MLS and public-record data. Rolling three-month numbers smooth out the swings you get in a town Nutley's size.

Nutley Home Prices: Fall 2026

  • Median sale price: $679,527, up 7.0% year over year (Redfin, Aug–Oct 2026)
  • Median price per square foot: $424.69, up 10.4% year over year (Redfin, Aug–Oct 2026)
  • Typical home value: $647,033, up 2.3% over the past year (Zillow Home Value Index, October 2026)

Why is the Redfin median higher than the Zillow number? They measure different things. Redfin's median covers only the homes that actually sold. Zillow's index estimates the typical value of all homes in town, sold or not. I lead with Redfin because it reflects real closed sales. I include Zillow because its steadier, slower-moving trend is a useful check.

The median also moves with the season and with which homes happen to sell. It peaked at $705,000 for the three months ending August 2026, was $700,000 through September, and eased to $679,527 through October (Redfin). That kind of fall dip is normal. It isn't a sign that prices are falling.

How Fast Are Nutley Homes Selling?

  • Median days on market: 33 days, 27 days faster than the same period last year (Redfin, Aug–Oct 2026)
  • Average sale-to-list ratio: 103.3% (Redfin, Aug–Oct 2026)
  • Share of homes sold above list price: about 67% (Redfin, Aug–Oct 2026)

Two out of three homes sold for more than their asking price. Buyers are still competing for well-priced homes.

Nutley Inventory and Sales Activity

  • Homes sold: 61, down 29.4% from a year ago (Redfin, Aug–Oct 2026)
  • New listings: 85, down 5.4% (Redfin, Aug–Oct 2026)
  • Homes for sale at period end: 58, down 22.0% (Redfin, Aug–Oct 2026)
  • Months of supply: 2.9, up from about 2.6 a year earlier (Redfin, Aug–Oct 2026)

Fewer homes for sale and fewer closings go together here. Many owners are staying put, so there's less to buy. Months of supply is still under three, a level that generally favors sellers.

Nearby Towns: How Nutley Compares

Here's a quick look at our neighbors. I've included only towns where I could find current published data.

Recent sales, three months ending October 2026 (Redfin):

Town

Median sale price

YoY

Median days on market

Months of supply

Nutley

$679,527

+7.0%

33

2.9

Clifton

$619,569

+3.3%

37

2.9

Montclair

$1,154,197

+18.4%

23

2.9

Glen Ridge

$1,349,062

+38.4%

16

1.4

Typical home values, October 2026 (Zillow Home Value Index):

Town

Typical value

1-year change

Nutley

$647,033

+2.3%

Bloomfield

$605,026

+3.4%

Belleville

$517,734

+3.5%

Lyndhurst

$647,558

+4.6%

Clifton

$600,047

+3.3%

Glen Ridge is a small market with only 22 sales in the period, so its year-over-year swing should be read with caution.

Essex County context (New Jersey REALTORS®, October 2026, single-family): The county median sales price was $734,000, up 0.5% from October 2025. Homes sold in 35 days on average and received 106.7% of list price. Inventory rose 10.8% to 772 homes, which is 2.8 months of supply.

Mortgage Rates This Fall

Freddie Mac's Primary Mortgage Market Survey put the 30-year fixed rate at an average of 7.11% for the week of November 12, 2026. That was its fourth straight weekly decline. A year earlier the rate was 6.24%, so borrowing costs are still noticeably higher than last fall. That helps explain the lower sales count.

What It Means for Buyers

  • Expect competition on well-priced homes. Most Nutley homes sold above asking this fall. Come in with your pre-approval in hand and be ready to move.
  • The season can work for you. Homes are taking a little longer to sell than they did in summer (33 days vs. 22 for the three months ending July). Late fall and winter often bring fewer competing buyers.
  • Budget for today's rates. At about 7%, small differences in price or rate add up. Talk with a lender early so you know your real monthly payment.

What It Means for Sellers

  • Pricing still drives results. Prices are up about 7% from last year, and the average home sold for about 3% over list. But roughly one in five homes still sold below list. Homes priced correctly from day one do best.
  • Low inventory is your advantage. With 58 homes for sale at the end of October, down 22% from last year, a well-prepared home stands out.
  • Expect a calmer pace than summer. Plan for about a month on market rather than a couple of weeks.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Nutley NJ a buyer's or seller's market right now?

It still leans toward sellers. In the three months ending October 2026, Nutley had 2.9 months of supply, homes sold at 103.3% of list on average, and about 67% sold above asking (Redfin).

What is the median home price in Nutley NJ?

The median sale price was $679,527 for the three months ending October 2026, up 7.0% year over year (Redfin). Zillow's typical home value for October 2026 was $647,033.

How long does it take to sell a house in Nutley NJ?

The median time on market was 33 days for August through October 2026, 27 days faster than a year earlier (Redfin).

Are home prices going up in Nutley NJ?

Yes, compared with last year. The median sale price rose 7.0% and price per square foot rose 10.4% year over year (Redfin, Aug–Oct 2026). Zillow's home value index rose 2.3% over the past year.

What are mortgage rates in New Jersey right now?

Freddie Mac's survey reports national averages, not state ones. For the week of November 12, 2026, the 30-year fixed averaged 7.11% and the 15-year fixed averaged 6.45%. Your own rate depends on your credit, down payment, and loan type.

How does Nutley compare to Clifton and Bloomfield?

Nutley's October 2026 Zillow typical home value ($647,033) is higher than Bloomfield's ($605,026) and Clifton's ($600,047). Nutley's Redfin median sale price is also higher than Clifton's ($679,527 vs. $619,569 for Aug–Oct 2026).

Thinking About a Move in Nutley?

Every home and every situation is different. These numbers are a starting point, not a price for your home. If you're thinking about buying or selling in Nutley or a nearby town, I'd be glad to walk you through what the latest sales mean for you.

Matt DeFede, Broker/Owner Realty Executives Elite Homes 653 Franklin Ave, Nutley, NJ

Sources

Work With Matthew

Whether you are a first-time homebuyer or a luxury client, Matthew De Fede is the go-to real estate broker in northern New Jersey. With his extensive experience, unparalleled market knowledge, and commitment to his client's success, Matthew is the perfect choice for anyone looking to buy or sell a home in the area.

Follow Me on Instagram